Thursday, September 21, 2006
See, my name is spelled K-N-A-P-P, and I specialize in K-I-D-N-A-P-P-I-N-G...
So, I gave my thoughts on "Kidnapped" this morning. What are yours?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
skip to main |
skip to sidebar
This blog has moved!
Alan Sepinwall can now be found at Rolling Stone.com
Search This Blog
Twitter Updates
Recommended Reading
- 6 Simple rules for commenting
- 30 Rock
- Band of Brothers
- Battlestar Galactica
- Best of the '00s in TV
- Best of the Year lists
- Breaking Bad
- Burn Notice
- Chuck
- Community
- Cupid ('98)
- Deadwood
- Dexter
- Firewall & Iceberg podcast
- Freaks and Geeks
- Friday Night Lights
- How I Met Your Mother
- In Treatment
- Lost
- Mad Men
- Parks and Recreation
- Party Down
- Scrubs
- Sons of Anarchy
- Sports Night
- The Office
- The Shield
- The Sopranos
- The Wire (season 1/newbies)
- The Wire (season 1/veterans)
- The Wire (season 2/newbies)
- The Wire (season 2/veterans)
- The Wire (season 3)
- The Wire (season 4)
- The Wire (season 5)
- United States of Tara
- What do the logos mean?
Interviews
- Bill Simmons (30 for 30)
- Chris Fedak (Chuck season 2 finale)
- Damon Lindelof (Lost season 5 premiere)
- David Simon (The Wire finale)
- Diablo Cody (United States of Tara premiere)
- Jon Hamm (Mad Men season 3 premiere)
- Josh Schwartz (Chuck season 2 premiere)
- Josh Schwartz (The OC finale)
- Joss Whedon (Dollhouse premiere)
- Kurt Sutter (Sons of Anarchy season 1 finale)
- Kurt Sutter (Sons of Anarchy season 2 finale)
- Matthew Weiner (Mad Men season 2 finale)
- Matthew Weiner (Mad Men season 3 premiere)
- Mike Schur (Parks and Recreation season 2 premiere)
- Ricky Gervais (Extras season 2)
- Rob Thomas & John Enbom (Party Down season 1 finale)
- Ronald D. Moore (Battlestar Galactica finale)
- Ronald D. Moore (Battlestar Galactica season 4 midway point)
- Shawn Ryan (The Shield finale)
- Vince Gilligan (Breaking Bad season 2 finale)
Friends of the blog
- Dan Fienberg's The Fien Print
- Ellen Gray
- Joe Adalian's TV MoJoe
- Undercover Black Man
- James Poniewozik's Tuned In
- Aaron Barnhart's TV Barn
- Tim Goodman's The Bastard Machine
- A List of Things Thrown Five Minutes Ago
- Rich Heldenfels' The HeldenFiles
- By Ken Levine
- Ed Bark's Above the Fold
- Phil Rosenthal's Tower Ticker
- Mo Ryan's The Watcher
- Melanie McFarland's IMDb TV Blog
- The House Next Door
Alan"s other writing
Blog Archive
-
▼
2006
(522)
-
▼
September
(54)
- He's a very neat monster
- Survivor: Racial harmony
- Grey's Anatomy: You're kidding, right?
- The Office: Stop. Hammermill time!
- Beautiful Betty
- Biker boy
- Gilmore Girls: Not quite right
- Studio 60: Is that all there is?
- Thoughts on Heroes?
- HIMYM & The Class: Apartments and houses
- David Fisher goes Hannibal Lecter
- Everyday people? Not anymore.
- Sunday night miscellany
- Wire week 4 talk for the On Demand'ers
- The Wire, "Home Rooms": Omar back!
- Grey's Anatomy: Shiva call
- Semi-Desperate
- My Name Is Earl: The Joy of kidnapping
- Survivor: Love at first sight?
- Six Degrees thoughts?
- The Office: Go the gay way
- Triple feature
- See, my name is spelled K-N-A-P-P, and I specializ...
- That's great, it starts with an earth -- er, nucle...
- The morning before the day after
- Smith: What's in a name?
- Everybody's a critic
- Rather than give you my "Prison Break" thoughts...
- So this thief walks into a bar...
- Studio 60: Crusty but benign
- HIMYM & The Class: In need of a switcheroo
- Wire week 3 talk for the On Demand'ers
- Aaron Stu? Kristin Sue? Mary Sue Tarses?
- Add it up
- The Wire, "Soft Eyes": Parallel lines
- If you are a fan of "The Office"...
- Survivor: Race Wars, initial impressions
- Corner boys, UFO Boy, fly boys, Emo Boy and Anne H...
- Rock Star: All over but the squealing
- The Wire: Mission ACCOMPLISHED
- Late morning links
- Wire talk for the On-Demand'ers
- The Wire, "Boys of Summer": Nailed shut
- The new season: best of the best
- Here come the weekend
- Make 'em laugh?
- 18 good years
- Rock Star: Clear skies?
- Rock Star: The originals
- The running man
- Quick "Wire" question
- A (be)labored point
- The man, they myth, the shotgun
- Will they or won't... oh, wait a minute
-
▼
September
(54)
9 comments:
I liked "Kidnapped". It was well acted (by Hutton especially) and intriguing. I think it has a different type of non-reality to it than other thrillers I've seen.
From its portrayal of a family who's literally in the stratosphere, class-wise, with their old continent sophistication; the self-made millionaire in Conrad Cain who has who-knows-what skeletons in his past; the symbolic and evocative names of its characters, like Cain, Knapp, and Virgil; the tagline ("Suspect everything"); all of it put me in the mind of British serial television mysteries like "Rebus" and "Poirot". For a movie comparison, look no further than "Gosford Park".
Is good.
Ack, not "Gosford Park"! That film is booooring and "Kidnapped" wasn't :-)
I found the show riveting (enough to sit and watch it without simultaneously multitasking on the computer, playing with my cats, etc., heh heh). I find the plot intriguing, I love Jeremy Sisto (he can take his shirt off any time, as far as I'm concerned), and Delroy Lindo & Timothy Hutton are awesome as usual. I'm very interested to see how they will sustain the conceit for a whole season. Not too worried about plot holes or season two at this point, either--I want to see how the story progresses before I worry about anything else.
What ABC show is going to go up against "Kidnapped"? Is it "The Nine" or something else?
Judging by last night's ratings, where "Kidnapped" got spanked by "CSI: NY" and a "Grey's Anatomy" repeat, I wouldn't be shocked if it wasn't even around by the time ABC premieres "The Nine" in a couple of weeks.
Sigh... NBC viewers just refuse to watch anything but "Law & Order" in this timeslot, don't they? The only plus is that "Vanished" will no doubt follow it out the door.
For some reason, I just think this show is a victim of "serialization overload." It's well done, it's well-acted, and the story is compelling enough, but it just comes oh-so-slightly short in the "sucking you in" department. And, with so many serialized dramas around this year, any show that doesn't suck you in immediately is going to fail.
That's why The Nine is going to do so well; that pilot was the only one that completely sucked me in and made me pay attention.
Delroy Lindo, nuff said. I firmly believe had this aired before Vanished it would have gotten more praise. From the pilot alone it has more intrigue and potential character development than Vanished could have ever hoped for. Time will tell, and I still plan on watching both, but rooting for the NBC rookie to pull it out.
I still like "Vanished" better.
"Kidnapped" was ok, but I thought it felt like an unfinished episode of "Without a Trace." Where was the intrigue? If there is some reason beyond wanting money that the boy was kidnapped, then they didn't do a very good job of making me wonder what was going on.
And what a bizarre ending. I felt no suspense. A phone ringing...ok. What exactly does that mean? I just didn't get it.
However, I love, love, love Jeremy Sisto. And Dana Delany. I just wish they had given us less bungling by the FBI and more drama between the family. The FBI should have come in much, much later. Like, they could have made it much more suspenseful, if the Delroy Lindo character near the very end of the episode finds out that his friend is still alive, instead of somewhere in the middle.
I agree with the idea that no one caring/noticing/reporting a shoot-out on the streets of NY was rather bizarre. And what about the kid who was let go? Wouldn't he have told the school or his parents what happened to him and why he is so traumatized? And why were the parents not panicking when their oldest daughter couldn't be reached?
I wanted it to be better and make a little more sense as to why I should continue to watch.
My complaint is probably the most superficial but ...
Would it kill NBC to get a different typestyle for the credits on each show? I can halfway understand Studio 60 cribbing their credit typeface from The West Wing, but why does Kidnapped have to use the exact same font?
Other than that, I liked it. Smart cops & smart villains always makes for good entertainment.
Excellent show - far better than Vanished, which I still continue to watch for some reason. The production values here are quite good; I really believe that the action is occurring in New York City. NBC has spent a lot of $$ promoting this show so I hope that they don't give up on it. Hutton, Delany, Sisto et al. clearly kept me riveted.
Post a Comment